• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Not Your Average Joe's - Peabody

At Not Your Average Joe's in Peabody, situated at the North Shore Mall, diners are treated to a vibrant culinary experience that goes beyond the ordinary. Known for its diverse menu, this beloved chain serves up delights like their renowned Coconut Shrimp and creamy Whipped Feta Dip, both of which evoke rave reviews. The warm, welcoming ambiance is complemented by attentive service, highlighted by staff knowledgeable about dietary restrictions. Diners can indulge in specialties such as the Bacon Bleu Burger and gluten-free options, creating a perfect spot for all occasions. With a selection of delightful desserts, including the decadent “Peanut Butter Thing,” it's clear that Not Your Average Joe's lives up to its name.

Not Your Average Joe's - Peabody: Reviews & Ratings

Maria Mongiardo
Maria Mongiardo

I visited Not Your Average Joe’s in Peabody at the North Shore Mall this past weekend . From what I’ve heard, this place was a total high school hangout hotspot . So, I was super excited to see what all the buzz was about at this beloved chain. To kick things off, we tried some of their mocktails - a perfect choice for anyone doing Dry January! And let’s talk about their table side focaccia bread with olive oil - simply divine! For starters, we had their whipped feta dip . It was creamy, reminiscent of tzatziki sauce, and served with marinated garbanzo beans, sesame crisps, cucumbers, and warm house pita chips - a solid 7/10. Next up, Buffalo Chicken Caribbean Tenders . These hand-breaded beauties were tossed in a mango-buffalo BBQ sauce and served with pineapple-jalapeno salsa and blue cheese dressing. Not too spicy, but a tender lover’s dream - 7/10. But the star of the appetizers? The Coconut Shrimp . The tangy sauce was a hit - this dish deserves a permanent spot on the menu! 9/10 for sure. Moving on to mains, we had their Chicken Poblano Enchiladas , Bacon Bleu Burger , and Mustard-Crusted Chicken . The enchiladas 7/10 and burger, both specials, were delicious, but my top pick? The Bacon Bleu Burger - an 8/10 thanks to the perfect pairing of bleu cheese. And those sweet potato fries ? Cooked to perfection. The mustard-crusted chicken, served with mashed potatoes and green beans, was a classic but maybe just lacked in flavor - 6/10. For dessert , we went all out! The “Peanut Butter Thing” was a colossal treat - a peanut butter and chocolate chunk vanilla ice cream pie slice, rolled in Oreo crumbs, topped with whipped cream, and drizzled with hot chocolate and caramel sauces - a heavenly 9/10. And the donuts in a bag , served with caramel sauce and apple slices, were great too, although I wished for a bit more cinnamon sugar - 8/10. Overall, Not Your Average Joe’s delivered a fantastic experience! With their extensive menu, you’re sure to find something tantalizing . Food : 7/10 Ambiance : 8/10 Affordability : 7/10

Joshua Shaw
Joshua Shaw

We ate in the early afternoon when it was quiet, and Kuldip waited on us and gave the absolute best service. He was very attentive and offered helpful suggestions, even paying attention to our dietary restrictions. I had the gluten free pizza and it was fantastic! A great restaurant with great service!

Nikki
Nikki

This was my first time here. I really liked how they had low carb items to choose from. The Spicy Cauliflower bites were so good. And the bread with the extra virgin olive oil was DELISH!Our waitress was so nice and really went above and beyond. I wish more waitresses were like her.

Jay Buckley
Jay Buckley

My wife and I just ate at Not Your Average Joes in Peabody. We had a great experience because our server whose name is Kuldip made it so enjoyable. He has worked at Joes for several decades and has a wealth of experience. He was so friendly and helpful that we will definitely come back because of him.

Jodi Renaud
Jodi Renaud

I got the cauliflower bites . They were soooo delicious. They came with a type of "slaw" with a blue cheese dressing. This and the famous focaccia bread with the dipping oil and Parmesan cheese was more than enough to fill me up. At first, truthfully, I was sad they said they didn't have the impossible burger anymore but the cauliflower was outstanding. Same with the spaghetti squash Bolognese. I would definitely order the cauliflower again. My server was great.- very attentive. The music and atmosphere is also very nice.

courtney smith
courtney smith

Kuldip Singh was absolutely incredible. Such a friendly guy he definitely made our experience great! Consistently refilled our drinks and was so knowledgeable! Such a great guy and great place.

Matteo Filippi
Matteo Filippi

Today was a 5 star experience for me. All the food was cooked perfectly. The space was a bit cold, only draw back. Was a cold day in New England. Coconut shrimp apps were done perfectly. I ordered a designated mule, which is a non alcoholic ginger based beverage .... I often order this and LOVE it. I had the korean beef noodle bowl, by far my favorite dish at this restaurant, and it did not disappoint today. Its also an elusive dish, as i have gone to NYAJ in 2 different locations over the last year that did not have the ingredients to order this dish. Well, im glad today I was not dissapointed. was done so perfectly in taste and texture, I gave it my rare 5th star. My wife ordered Herb crusted haddock. she loved it. no desert today, just a beautiful subtle end to the meal with a non- alcoholic berry spritzer to clean the palate. our server was perfect. timing, demeanor and engagement

Aleja Gagnon
Aleja Gagnon

First time at this chain, and it didn't disappoint at all. We went on Mothers Day without a reservation with a party of 5, and we were able to be seated right away. We all had sandwiches for lunch. The chicken caprese, the Cuban, a hamburger, and a chicken btl. All with fries on the side and lemonades. We also got a chocolate chip cookie explosion to share.

Location

If you’re in Peabody, Massachusetts, and hunting for a noteworthy dining experience, look no further than Not Your Average Joe's. Nestled conveniently at 210 Andover St, Unit P127, this vibrant eatery has made a name for itself as more than just a casual spot to grab a bite. It’s a culinary haven that boasts a menu brimming with diverse options, catering to a variety of tastes and dietary preferences.

Upon entering Not Your Average Joe's, you’re greeted with an inviting atmosphere, perfect for family gatherings, casual outings, or simply unwinding after a long day. The ambiance is enhanced by attentive staff, like Kuldip, who have garnered countless praises from regulars for their dedication to excellent service. Reviews reveal that many patrons feel personally cared for, thanks to wait staff who are not just knowledgeable but genuinely passionate about enhancing customers' dining experiences.

The menu showcases a delightful selection of dishes that can please just about anyone. From mocktails ideal for the health-conscious, like during Dry January, to the indulgent table side focaccia served with olive oil, everything here feels like a celebration of flavors. Guests rave about the creamy whipped feta dip, creatively paired with marinated garbanzo beans and crispy sesame snacks—an appetizer that surely sets the tone for the meal ahead.

Among the standout dishes are the Coconut Shrimp, generously praised for their tangy sauce and recommended as a must-try. The Bacon Bleu Burger, featuring a perfect harmony of flavors and accompanied by sweet potato fries, also shines brightly on the menu, offering both taste and satisfaction. Vegan and gluten-free options, like the gluten-free pizza and spicy cauliflower bites, complete this diverse offering, making it a haven for diners with specific dietary needs.

No meal would be complete without dessert, and the “Peanut Butter Thing” certainly doesn’t disappoint. Described as a heavenly fusion of peanut butter, chocolate, and cream, it’s a fitting conclusion to an already satisfying meal. The donuts in a bag deliver additional cheer, served with caramel sauce that sweetens the experience.

Overall, Not Your Average Joe's - Peabody delivers a fulfilling dining experience rich in hospitality and culinary flair. The positive reviews can’t be overstated; with dishes that range from delectable entrées to divine desserts, each meal promises to be memorable. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular, you’re sure to leave with a smile and a plan to return!